Last month I wrote an article called Combining World War II Research on Fold3 with Your Ancestry Family Tree. This month we will look at Ancestry family trees in another way.
Ancestry family trees offer researchers a way to organize their research and share it with the world. We can search for a multitude of records and attach them to individuals on our tree, creating facts about their lives. One question we should ask ourselves is, “Are we attaching records correctly?”
Genealogy is a learning process for all of us, and many of us started by attaching everything, regardless of whether it was accurate, until our education developed further. Ancestry offers researchers information through this blog and Ancestry Academy. Ancestry Academy offers many courses to help new and experienced researchers learn about the records and help them create more accurate family trees. Understanding the records and how to properly attach them to our tree, benefits everyone.
I have seen many cases of World War II research where the facts are partially or completely incorrect, leading those browsing trees to assume, and often attach, incorrect information to their own trees. Using a few tips, researchers can better document their World War II ancestors in their family trees. Let me illustrate what I mean.
William F. Cowart
William F. Cowart was a Marine during World War II. Born. 21 February 1922 at Reform, AL. Killed In Action on 20 November 1943 at Tarawa. Remains never recovered. Serial number 471443. Final unit: C Company 2ndAmpTrBn, 2ndMarDiv. (Source: USMC Casualty Card for William F. Cowart, serial no. 471443. Marine Corps History Division, Quantico, VA. Death Certificate for William F. Cowart, serial no. 471443. Individual Deceased Personnel File, AHRC Ft. Knox, KY.)
One family tree for William F. Cowart contains information attached about his military service, death, and burial which is somewhat inaccurate. There are ways to improve on this information by looking at the records more carefully.
Death Fact: The date of death listed is 21 November 1943. However, this date is incorrect due to indexing. If you examine the Headstone Application it has typed 21 November 1943 as the death date. But the military examined this record to ensure the facts were correct and crossed out 21 and wrote 20. According to his Individual Deceased Personnel File and USMC Casualty Card, he was Killed In Action the 20th of November. Cowart’s father completed or helped complete this Headstone Application. Families made errors all the time. Usually the government checked the information, but not always.
Fixing the Fact in the tree: The date should be changed to 20 November 1943. A notation could also be made in the Description Field of the fact to explain why the date is 20 and not 21 November. Unfortunately the death date cannot be changed in the index because the only change allowed is the year.
Burial Fact: The Burial is listed as Ethelsville, Pickens County, Alabama. Three sources “prove” this fact. Two Find A Grave entries and the U.S. Headstone Application. However, if the headstone/marker is examined when the researcher goes to FindAGrave, they will see it says “In Memory Of.” This is a memorial stone only. Cowart is not buried in Alabama.
Continuing the examination of Find A Grave entries for Cowart, we will also see several which were created by various sources, including the American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) for all those buried overseas or listed on a Wall or Tablet of the Missing, as Cowart is. One issue with Find A Grave, that I have no idea how to solve, is the multiple entries for Cowart make him look like he is his own sibling.
Researchers should examine all entries for Cowart because they provide different details. Together, they help paint a picture of Cowart’s life.
Further examining the Headstone Application, we see at the top it says NONRECOVERABLE. This means Cowart’s remains were never found.
Fixing the Burial Fact in the tree: Without the Individual Deceased Personnel File (IDPF) obtained from Ft. Knox, KY, Ancestry users will not know Cowart was actually identified and buried soon after the Battle of Tarawa, ON Tarawa. Unfortunately with the chaos of war, when the Marines left the island and the Navy Seabees arrived, they “beautified” the cemetery and many of the identified dead were now “lost.” Families received letters after the war stating their sons could not be found. Most are still “lost” today.
The burial fact can remain but the place of burial should not say Alabama. At the very least, until or if Cowart is recovered, it should say Tarawa or Gilbert Islands. If a researcher has the IDPF and can document a burial date, then it should be added.
A note in the description field of the fact could indicate Cowart’s remains were not recovered and he is not buried in Alabama. Only a memorial stone exists for him there.
Fold3.com Records: Finally, Fold3.com offers researchers the ability to search for documents which help tell the story of their soldier. When we search for only William Cowart’s name on Fold3, a couple of entries appear, which we can also find on Ancestry. However, if we search within the WWII War Diaries for Tarawa, 2nd Marine, we find the Second Marine Division War Diary for November 1943.
This document likely does not list Cowart by name, but provides historical context to his story. These records may also be attached to individuals in our family trees.
Fixing Fold3 Records in the tree: Each page of a record can be attached individually and will create a new fact unless we download the document and then add it to a specific fact. If you only attach one page out of a full document, consider adding a note in the description field as to what this is and what other information it contains. You might also consider writing up a short document in Word summarizing the information, and attaching that to the fact.
We all have a lot to learn about our families, the records available, and how best to document this in our family trees. Being as accurate as possible helps to build more accurate trees and on some level, educate others how to do the research. It also further builds our relatives stories as we continue to honor their memories with our research.