Ancestry.com

Israel Arbeiter Lands in Poland

Posted by Nick Cifuentes on April 24, 2012 in Social Media, Stories

Contributed by Tim Gray, chairman of the non-profit WWII Foundation. For more information about the foundation, visit www.wwiifoundation.org

Just prior to boarding our Lufthansa flight from Boston’s Logan airport to Munich, Germany and then on to Warsaw, Poland I gave Holocaust survivor Israel Arbeiter a copy of a book I just finished. It’s called “Auschwitz” by British historian Laurence Rees.

There is something very inadequate about handing an Auschwitz survivor a book on Auschwitz. What will it say that he didn’t already experience himself?

Don’t get me wrong, from my perspective Rees’ book was very, very good. It opened my eyes to many things about the camp I never knew. It’s a book I would highly recommend to anyone who wants to know more about the most infamous of the Nazis concentration camps. It’s just that handing it to a man who lived it personally is an awkward feeling. Kind of like giving Neil Armstrong a book about the moon.

To tell you the truth I am not sure how I am going to react to visiting Auschwitz and making the trip with an actual survivor. Trying to see it through his eyes will be difficult. Somehow words seem hollow when trying the describe what he went through. Maybe it’s best just to let Izzy speak for himself. Isn’t that the correct way to hear about history, from those who actually lived it?

I have spent my entire life reading about the people and major battles of World War II. We have filmed all over the world, from Guadalcanal to Normandy, France (9 times) to Holland, Belgium, Luxembourg and Germany. But Auschwitz is something different. I like to call it a game changer. Guadalcanal was in some ways like that. I mean who ever expects to go to Guadalcanal and experience the jungle where so much savagery occurred? It’s 36 hour trip from Boston. But in a way it changed my perception. I feel fortunate to have visited a place most Americans couldn’t find on a map during World War II and would still have trouble today. Yet, to anyone who has studied the war, the Solomon Islands and Guadalcanal was a watershed moment in WWII in the Pacific.

I have interviewed many veterans and survivors of World War II. Many told stories that were emotionally difficult for them to talk about. Many cried. I have also stood in American cemeteries in Holland, Normandy and Luxembourg where the white crosses and stars of David stretched on and on. Full of boys who were barely old enough to buy a beer when they were killed on places like Omaha Beach, the Waal River crossing and in the Battle of the Bulge. But Auschwitz is different and visiting the camp with a survivor will be emotional. How can it not be? Of the 1.3 million who came through the gates of Auschwitz-Birkenau, 1.1 million were killed. If hell had a physical street address, this would be it.

I speak with Israel Arbeiter about the book, the pictures in it. The tattoo on his arm which reads A18651. We look at the photos of the Auschwitz SS commander Rudolf Hoss who was responsible for all the killings in the camp. It all feels so inadequate.

We have arrived in Poland. Later today we have a special meeting with the Chief Rabbi of Poland. Tomorrow we visit Izzy’s home city of Plonsk where it has the potential to be a very special day if all falls into place.

Please watch the video below to hear Israel Arbeiter’s thoughts on arriving back in Warsaw today.

Please stay tuned as we post daily updates on Izzy Arbeiter’s return to Poland and Germany.

Tim Gray is Chairman of the non-profit WWII Foundation. To learn more about the WWII Foundation and to donate to their projects, including the educational documentary on Israel Arbeiter’s return to Poland and Germany, please visit www.wwiifoundation.org

 

6 comments

Comments
1 Scott SumApril 24, 2012 at 10:42 am

I apologize in advance if this message didn’t make it to the party for whom it is intended. I simply wanted to give some feedback to Ancestry.com regarding how shameful I think it is to charge people money to have access to your files, which should be available to the public due to the freedom of information act. Furthermore, as a member of the LDS community I was taught that genealogy is an important part of history, and yet I find that this very history has been used to prevent use without being an exclusive member. Shame on you for your greed and selfishness. Sincerely, Scott Sum

2 Andy HatchettApril 24, 2012 at 11:27 am

Scott Sum Re: #1

Anytime you and/or the LDS want to start paying for the expenses for staff, servers, acquisitions, indexing, etc. of the information Ancestry puts online- just say so.

Btw- could I use the Freedom of Information Act to obtain a full set of the Bylaws and complete Organizational Chart of both the LDS and FamilySearch?

Andy Hatchett
http://www.fhiso.org

3 Caroline GurneyApril 24, 2012 at 2:21 pm

Scott, did you actually read this blog post before commenting? It’s about a brave Holocaust survivor returning to confront the horrors he endured in Poland at the hands of the Nazis. Izzy lost his whole family and was forced to work as a slave labourer, constantly facing death himself. This is most definitely NOT the place to write complaints about your access to records for your hobby. It feels like you just desecrated sacred ground.

4 Ceramic ToysApril 25, 2012 at 2:18 am

Rathissh Ceramics, Virddhachalam, Tamil Nadu, India is one of the leading Manufacturers, Suppliers and Exporters of Ceramic Products, Ceramic Toys, Plaster of Paris Powder, Refractory, Procelin Special Items, Vegetables and Herbal Products.

5 Pat SecordApril 25, 2012 at 4:24 am

Re: #1 Scott – I have to totally agree with Andy (#2) and Caroline (#3). Why do so many people think that Ancestry.com should be free? The fact is, no one is forcing anyone to pay for this info. Most of this info can be obtained by doing all the work yourself (you know, spend your money on gas to visit courthouses, cemeteries, libraries, etc.), and of course the time it all takes. And to discuss your annoyance on this particular blog article is just plain disrespectful.

6 darlene8705April 25, 2012 at 11:56 am

Thankyou for your time and effort to help others.
With many people trying to deny the hollicost, this is a great effort, particularly when you’re revisiting the sites with an actually “participant” of the holicost. Thankyou.
Darlene 8705

About the Ancestry.com blog

Here you will find informational, and sometimes fun, posts from the folks behind the scenes here at Ancestry.com. We hope you’ll notice just how passionate we are about family history and about the products we’re building to help connect families over distance and time.

Visit Ancestry.com
Notifications

Receive updates from the Ancestry.com blog Learn more